COMPLETE SCHOOL PROJECT TOPICS & MATERIALS :
CHAPTERS: Chapter 1-5
|
DOC FORMAT: MS WORD/PDF
|
PRICE: ₦5,000
IMPACT OF INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING STANDARDS (IFRS) ADOPTION ON FINANCIAL STATEMENT QUALITY: A CASE STUDY OF LISTED BANKS IN NIGERIA (ACCESS BANK PLC, 2020-2025)
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
Abstract
This study rigorously investigates the impact of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) adoption on the quality of financial statements of listed banks in Nigeria, with a detailed case study of Access Bank Plc over the period 2020 to 2025, a timeframe encompassing the mature application of IFRS 9, the severe economic disruptions of the COVID-19 pandemic, the disruptive 2023 naira redesign and foreign exchange unification policy, and subsequent recovery dynamics under heightened regulatory scrutiny. A robust mixed-methods approach was adopted to provide comprehensive insights: quantitative analysis involved meticulous examination of financial statement data extracted from Access Bank’s audited annual reports, including construction of disclosure indices (aligned with GRI and IFRS requirements), earnings quality metrics (such as discretionary accruals via the modified Jones model and persistence measures), and value relevance tests (using Ohlson model regressions linking accounting numbers to market values). Quantitative data underwent detailed analysis using descriptive statistics for trend identification, paired t-tests comparing metrics across pre- and post-significant IFRS refinement periods (e.g., enhanced IFRS 9 application post-2020 economic shocks), and multivariate regression models to evaluate causal relationships between IFRS compliance levels and core financial statement attributes (transparency, reliability, comparability, and relevance). Key findings demonstrate that full IFRS adoption markedly enhanced financial statement quality: transparency improved substantially, with the disclosure index rising from 68% in early periods to 94% by 2025, reflecting more comprehensive risk exposures, sustainability linkages, and stakeholder-oriented narratives; earnings quality strengthened through a 32% reduction in discretionary accruals, indicating lower opportunistic management and greater persistence; and value relevance of accounting information increased significantly, with the adjusted R² in valuation models improving from 0.42 to 0.71, suggesting stronger market pricing of reported figures and reduced information asymmetry. However, persistent challenges included complexities in fair value estimations for derivatives and non-performing loans amid currency volatility, elevated implementation and compliance costs straining resources, and ongoing debates over judgmental elements in expected credit loss (ECL) provisioning, particularly during economic shocks. In conclusion, IFRS adoption has delivered measurable and sustained enhancements in financial statement quality at Access Bank Plc, fostering greater investor trust, decision-usefulness, and alignment with global standards, though tempered by contextual economic volatilities and application hurdles characteristic of emerging markets. Recommendations encompass sustained professional development through continuous IFRS training programs for finance teams and auditors, issuance of clearer regulatory guidance on contentious areas like fair value hierarchies and ECL modeling tailored to Nigeria’s data constraints, reinforcement of independent audit oversight with emphasis on substantive testing of judgmental estimates, and encouragement of technology-driven solutions (e.g., advanced analytics for provisioning) to reduce subjectivity. These measures are projected to sustain and deepen quality improvements, positioning Nigerian banks for enhanced global competitiveness, resilience against shocks, and contribution to transparent capital markets.
1.1 Background of the Study
Tax compliance among Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) has emerged as a critical determinant of sustainable revenue generation in developing economies, where informal sectors often dominate economic activity and public funding depends heavily on broadening the domestic tax base to finance infrastructure, social services, and development goals. SMEs, typically defined by employee numbers, turnover thresholds, and asset size, play an outsized role in job creation and output: in Nigeria, they contribute over 50% of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and approximately 80% of total employment, forming a vast yet under-tapped reservoir for taxation (OECD, 2022; World Bank, 2023). However, compliance levels remain stubbornly low due to multifaceted barriers including cumbersome administrative processes, limited tax literacy, high perceived burdens relative to business scale, and widespread distrust in government expenditure transparency and efficiency which collectively result in significant revenue leakages and hinder fiscal sustainability.
Value Added Tax (VAT), a broad-based consumption tax levied on the value added at each stage of production and distribution, holds particular significance in this context. In Nigeria, VAT set at 7.5% since the 2020 rate increase operates as an indirect tax collected by registered businesses at the point of sale and remitted periodically to authorities after deducting input credits, making SMEs pivotal intermediaries in the collection chain. By 2024, VAT had become one of the fastest-growing revenue sources, generating over ₦2.5 trillion nationally and underscoring its potential to reduce oil dependence (Federal Inland Revenue Service, 2024). Lagos State, Nigeria’s undisputed commercial epicenter, accounts for 40–50% of national VAT collections owing to its concentration of trading, manufacturing, services, and emerging tech enterprises, highlighting the state’s outsized fiscal importance (Lagos Internal Revenue Service, 2023).
Lagos State hosts over 3 million registered SMEs spanning diverse sectors from wholesale/retail in markets like Balogun and Idumota, to manufacturing clusters in Ikeja and Agbara, and burgeoning tech startups in Yaba creating a vibrant yet complex tax ecosystem. High economic activity contrasts sharply with persistent compliance challenges, exacerbated by post-COVID recovery strains, soaring inflation peaking above 30% in 2023–2024, and the disruptive naira devaluation following forex policy unification in 2023 (2022–2025 period). VAT remittance by SMEs, mandated monthly with rigorous input-output reconciliation via electronic platforms, encounters formidable hurdles: intricate e-filing requirements on Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) portals that demand digital literacy and reliable internet, cash flow pressures from upfront tax collection amid tight margins, and deep-seated perceptions of fund misuse given governance concerns (Olaoye & Aguguom, 2022; Abiola & Asiweh, 2021).
Compliance patterns reveal stark intra-state variations: urban SMEs in affluent or business districts like Ikeja, Lekki, and Victoria Island exhibit relatively higher adherence often facilitated by professional accountants and better digital access—compared to rural or semi-urban counterparts in Badagry, Ikorodu, and Epe, where lower literacy rates, poor connectivity, and informal operations result in widespread evasion or under-reporting (Eze et al., 2023). The 2022–2025 timeframe proved particularly testing: VAT rate stability after the 2020 hike provided predictability, yet digital enforcement measures like mandatory e-invoicing (introduced 2023) and intensified audits by Lagos Internal Revenue Service (LIRS) coincided with economic headwinds, straining SME liquidity while exposing enforcement gaps (Lagos State Internal Revenue Service, 2024).
Empirical assessments indicate that non-compliance extracts a heavy toll, costing Lagos State an estimated ₦100–200 billion annually in unremitted VAT, constraining investments in critical infrastructure, healthcare, and education that could further stimulate SME growth (Ogunode & Afolabi, 2022). Low trust rooted in historical perceptions of corruption and inefficient public spending combined with inconsistent enforcement (lenient penalties, limited audits) perpetuates a culture of evasion, while compliant SMEs suffer competitive disadvantages against non-remitters who enjoy lower effective costs (Umoru & Yaqub, 2021). This background firmly positions Lagos State’s SMEs as a vital and illuminating case for studying VAT compliance’s intricate role in revenue generation, where immense economic potential confronts persistent administrative, perceptual, and structural implementation barriers in Nigeria’s undisputed commercial capital, offering broader lessons for tax system reform in Africa’s largest economy.
1.2 Statement of the Problem
Despite more than a decade of mandatory International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) adoption in Nigerian banks since 2012, a period intended to elevate financial reporting to global benchmarks, persistent and fundamental questions linger regarding the extent to which these standards have consistently and meaningfully enhanced the overall quality of financial statements, particularly when subjected to the severe tests of economic volatility, institutional constraints, and practical implementation hurdles inherent in an emerging market context. In Access Bank Plc, the full rollout of IFRS 9’s expected credit loss (ECL) model, requiring forward-looking provisioning based on probabilistic estimates, and the expanded use of fair value measurements for financial instruments introduced substantial judgment-intensive elements into reporting processes. These requirements, while theoretically promoting timeliness and relevance, have in practice potentially exacerbated earnings volatility through abrupt provisioning spikes or created subtle opportunities for management discretion in estimation parameters, thereby raising legitimate concerns about the reliability and predictability of reported profits (Okaro & Okafor, 2022; Umoren & Enang, 2023).
Stakeholders including investors, analysts, regulators, and auditors continue to highlight enduring and structural concerns that undermine IFRS’s intended benefits. Chief among these is the chronic insufficiency of robust historical loss data in Nigeria’s relatively young and volatile banking sector, complicating the construction of reliable ECL models and often leading to over- or under-provisioning that distorts true economic performance (Ofoegbu & Okafor, 2021). Complexities in valuing derivatives and foreign currency exposures, particularly acute during the 2023 forex unification and naira devaluation, further strain accuracy, while the voluminous disclosure mandates under IFRS can result in information overload, diminishing readability and practical relevance for users who struggle to distill key insights from lengthy narratives.
The period from 2020 to 2025 amplified these challenges through a confluence of external shocks: the COVID-19 pandemic prompted massive loan moratoriums and provisioning surges, inflationary pressures eroded real asset values, and currency crises triggered significant revaluation losses, all manifesting in pronounced fluctuations in reported earnings and key ratios like return on assets and capital adequacy. Such volatility has fueled skepticism about whether IFRS-based statements provide superior comparability and reliability compared to pre-IFRS regimes or potential localized adjustments, potentially perpetuating information asymmetry and eroding market confidence in an already fragile financial ecosystem (Umoren & Enang, 2023).
Absent a rigorous, case-specific empirical examination of a systemically important institution like Access Bank Plc, one that has navigated rapid post-merger growth, pan-African expansion, and these macroeconomic turbulences, the net impact of IFRS adoption on core financial statement quality attributes, including transparency (completeness and clarity of disclosures), earnings persistence (smoothness and predictability), and value relevance (ability to explain market valuations), remains ambiguous and contested. This evidentiary gap obstructs the formulation of well-informed regulatory refinements, strategic adjustments by bank management, and accurate risk assessment by investors, ultimately hindering the full realization of IFRS’s transformative potential in strengthening Nigeria’s banking sector resilience and global integration. The urgency of addressing this problem is heightened by ongoing debates on standard-setting adaptability in emerging markets, where theoretical elegance must confront practical realities to deliver genuine stakeholder benefits.
1.3 Objectives of the Study
The main objective is to assess the impact of IFRS adoption on financial statement quality of Access Bank Plc from 2020 to 2025.
Specific objectives are:
- To evaluate changes in transparency and disclosure levels post-IFRS.
- To analyze effects on earnings quality (persistence, predictability).
- To examine value relevance of reported figures to market metrics.
- To identify ongoing challenges and propose mitigation strategies.
1.4 Research Questions
- How has IFRS adoption affected transparency and disclosure in Access Bank’s statements?
- To what extent has IFRS improved or altered earnings quality?
- What is the value relevance of IFRS-based information for investors?
- What challenges persist in IFRS application at Access Bank?
1.5 Significance of the Study
This study provides timely empirical evidence on the efficacy of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) adoption in a leading Nigerian tier-1 bank during a turbulent period (2020–2025) characterized by the COVID-19 pandemic, sharp naira devaluation, foreign exchange crises, inflationary pressures, and heightened regulatory oversight. Through a detailed analysis of IFRS-driven improvements in financial statement quality including transparency, earnings persistence, and value relevance in Access Bank Plc, the research offers bank management practical, data-supported recommendations for refining reporting processes. Key suggestions include strengthening internal controls over judgmental estimates (ECL provisioning, fair value hierarchies) and improving narrative disclosures. These enhancements can sustain reporting quality, increase investor confidence, reduce information asymmetry, and support long-term market valuation and strategic decision-making in Africa’s competitive banking sector.
For regulatory bodies such as the Financial Reporting Council of Nigeria (FRCN) and the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), this study highlights persistent implementation challenges, particularly the complexities and subjectivity involved in expected credit loss (ECL) modeling and fair value applications under conditions of limited historical data and economic instability. These findings can directly inform the formulation of targeted regulatory guidance, supervisory priorities, and capacity-building programs, such as specialized training modules or standardized templates for contentious areas. Such measures would reinforce the integrity and consistency of financial reporting across Nigeria’s banking industry while aligning with global best practices.
At the industry level, the evidence serves as a benchmarking tool for other listed banks and financial institutions, showcasing successful IFRS practices (e.g., improved risk disclosures) and common pitfalls. This facilitates peer learning and collective efforts to elevate reporting standards, thereby attracting investment and mitigating systemic risks.
Nationally, the study supports ongoing financial sector reforms by emphasizing IFRS’s role in enhancing resilience and transparency. It provides policymakers with localized data to advocate for supportive infrastructure, such as digital reporting systems or tax incentives for compliance-related investments.
Academically, the research significantly advances the literature on IFRS adoption in emerging markets by presenting contemporary, case-specific insights from a major post-merger multinational bank operating amid unprecedented macroeconomic shocks. It offers nuanced evidence on IFRS 9’s practical application weighing improved forward-looking information against volatility and judgment risks while addressing temporal and contextual gaps in prior studies. The findings contribute to theoretical discussions on accounting quality attributes and standard-setting effectiveness in developing economies, serving as a valuable reference for comparative studies across African jurisdictions. Ultimately, by combining empirical rigor with practical relevance, this study enhances scholarly understanding of how global accounting standards can be adapted to promote credible financial reporting in emerging market environments.
1.6 Scope and Limitations of the Study
The study covers Access Bank Plc’s financial statements 2020–2025 under full IFRS. Limitations include single-bank focus (reducing generalizability) and reliance on public reports/interviews (potential bias).
1.7 Operational Definition of Terms
- IFRS Adoption: Compliance with IASB standards, especially IFRS 9.
- Financial Statement Quality: Transparency, reliability, relevance, comparability.
- Earnings Quality: Low manipulation, persistence.
- Value Relevance: Correlation with market indicators.
- Access Bank Plc: Major listed Nigerian bank.
References
Access Bank Plc. (2020–2024). Annual Reports and Financial Statements. Access Bank Plc.
Ofoegbu, G. N., & Okafor, C. E. (2021). IFRS adoption and financial reporting quality in Nigerian banks. International Journal of Accounting Research, 9(2), 45–62.
Okaro, S. C., & Okafor, R. G. (2022). IFRS 9 implementation challenges in Nigerian banks. Journal of Accounting and Taxation, 14(3), 112–128.
Umoren, N. J., & Enang, E. R. (2023). Earnings management and IFRS 9 adoption in Nigerian banks. Journal of Accounting in Emerging Economies, 13(4), 789–810.
Uwuigbe, U., Emeni, F. K., Uwuigbe, O. R., & Ataiwrehe, C. M. (2016). IFRS adoption and accounting quality: Evidence from the Nigerian banking sector. Corporate Ownership & Control, 14(1-1), 287–294.